Eli Manning Claims To Be A Top 5 QB??

[Badass2000GT]

You might like to toss Manning's salad, besides that there is no way in hell he is better than Brady. That is a punchline to a joke. I don't even like Brady either, I think he's a queer.

We saw what happens to the patriots when Brady went out for almost a season. They went 11-5. Do you really see the colts have a winning record if Manning went out for most of the season? Not really. This is the only reason I say Manning is better then Brady.

[Nash B.]

You can't say that the Colts wouldn't do well without Manning; nobody expected the Patriots to do well without Brady. Also, you can't rate Manning higher than Brady just because Brady is surrounded by more talent.

[Badass2000GT]

You can't say that the Colts wouldn't do well without Manning; nobody expected the Patriots to do well without Brady. Also, you can't rate Manning higher than Brady just because Brady is surrounded by more talent.

Yeah ok.

[Nash B.]

Brady has thrown 1 interception in 4 Super Bowls. Manning has thrown 1 in each of his 2.

[Silverback]

He's not even up for consideration on my fantasy league, but ya, 9-12th

I guess it all depends on scoring in your league.

In Yahoo, with default settings, based on last year's points.

Brady
P Manning
Rogers
Brees
Vick
Rivers
E Manning
Ryan
Freeman
Schaub

But in a PPR league with points adujstments last year's points leaders looks like this:

Brady
Rodgers
P Manning
Vick
Brees
Rivers
E Manning
Ryan
Freeman
Schaub

And finally in our completely point outrageous league with all bonuses increased points on all counts, rankings look like this:

P Manning
Brees
Brady
Rivers
Rodgers
E Manning
Schaub
Ryan
Palmer (out)
Freeman

[Badass2000GT]

Brady has thrown 1 interception in 4 Super Bowls. Manning has thrown 1 in each of his 2.

LOL so?

[Nash B.]

LOL so?

Just showing how hard it is to show that Manning, or anybody else, is a better quarterback than Brady.

[Geor!]

When has either Manning been twice?

[mstng86]

When has either Manning been twice?

hmm Peyton beat Chicago, and then lost to NO.

But I don't count the NO Super Bowl either.

[Geor!]

hmm Peyton beat Chicago, and then lost to NO.

But I don't count the NO Super Bowl either.

Oh yeah, I forgot about that. Shows you how much I care about either the Saints or the Colts lol.

[mstng86]

Oh yeah, I forgot about that. Shows you how much I care about either the Saints or the Colts lol.

I think that whole SB was a conspiracy to help New Orleans. They needed something to bring in money, and who better to throw a game for the Saints than their native son, Peyton.

[clevelandkid]

Eli was something like 4th in yardage last year and 5th in TDs... I guess if you only looked at those two stats, he would have an argument for himself being top 5.

[mstng86]

Eli was something like 4th in yardage last year and 5th in TDs... I guess if you only looked at those two stats, he would have an argument for himself being top 5.

.....with 25 interceptions. Almost a 1:1 ratio of td:int. That is hard to do past the 25 mark.

[pHILSANITY07]

Eli is average at best IMO. He can be either really good or really bad. His best performance was the 2007 postseason when they beat the Bucaneers, Cowboys, Packers, and then the Patriots.