Genesis or Phill Collins?

[Denny]

Posting up all those semi-good ones... LOL Post up the best!

[Vertnut]

Sales does not equal talent. Phil Collins was just more marketable by comparison. To be fair, though, they both hit their respective peaks in different genres and at different times. They're an apples to oranges comparison, and they happened to have good artistic chemistry for a while. I like them both, too, though.

You're not understanding what I'm saying about recording executives equating talent to money, but no matter. After further review, Collins had/has a lot more talent than Gabriel.

"Talent" is subjective.

[Denny]

Favorite Peter Gabiel




Favorite Phil Collins




Phil gettin' down with Chester Thompson

[YALE]

You're not understanding what I'm saying about recording executives equating talent to money, but no matter. After further review, Collins had/has a lot more talent than Gabriel.

"Talent" is subjective.

I know what you're saying. Collins was more marketable. Gabriel gets the rep as the better, "artist." We're talking about the difference between artistry and artisanship.

[Denny]

Drum it up!!!

[Denny]

Games Without Frontiers (Uncensored)


Straight off the vinyl!!!

[Denny]

And LOL @ this discussion!!!

Blue is more blue than Red is more red!

[Geor!]

My favorite Genesis song and arguably one of the best prog rock songs of all time:




My second favorite:

[Denny]

Leave it to you to come up with some good choices.

[Geor!]

Leave it to you to come up with some good choices.

See, I'm not a complete tool.

[Pro88LX]

[Denny]

See, I'm not a complete tool.

Nah, you're toolless.

[Geor!]

That's not what Jessica Oliva said.