GLOCK (compact 23) VS. Springfield (xd compact .40)

[Craizie]

+1 for the p30.

[Mach1Run]

Have you tried out the XDS yet?

[bybotie]

I have a XDM and an XDS. XDS is a great carry gun but only holds 5 rounds. You can get a extension mag to hold 7.

[brandon01rt]

XDM 3.8 is the way to go.

[Rick Modena]

fuck, youre annoying.

No shit. The OP only asked for two options and the USP was not one of them.

I vote G-23, I love my G-32 and carry it everywhere I go. I only have it stacked with 7 rounds that makes it even that much more carry friendly.

[CRASH]

My every day carry gun is a sub-compact XD40. It shoots very well, carries nicely with an in-the-waistband holster at the 1 o'clock position and I've never had a problem with it FTF or FTE. I also carry it with the extended mag, so I have 13 rounds total.

I've only shot a Glock 17 so that is my only comparison. I like the way the XD feels in my hand and for a 3" barrel shoots pretty damn good groups.

[BlackGT]

No shit. The OP only asked for two options and the USP was not one of them.

I vote G-23, I love my G-32 and carry it everywhere I go. I only have it stacked with 7 rounds that makes it even that much more carry friendly.

6 Less rounds make that much difference in carry comfort?

I also carry a G-32 every day...

[KBScobravert]

fuck, youre annoying.

come on where is the sense of humor? it is expected of him to post an HK offering. it is just the way things are.

of the two I would go XD but I am partial to them since I own quite a few of the SA XD guns myself. nothing wrong with a glock though.

[Quadforce]

New?

yes sir

[Moose242]

No shit. The OP only asked for two options and the USP was not one of them.

I vote G-23, I love my G-32 and carry it everywhere I go. I only have it stacked with 7 rounds that makes it even that much more carry friendly.

I like it when people provide me with good alternatives to things I am thinking about purchasing.

[Rick Modena]

6 Less rounds make that much difference in carry comfort?

I also carry a G-32 every day...

Weight for me, more rounds make the gun heavier. And really you only need a few rounds. How many times (other than LE) have you heard of multiple rounds begin fired by non LE in a shooting. Most of the time it was one or three. That being said I do carry a full magazine in the car just in case zombies attack and im out on the road.

[Rick Modena]

I like it when people provide me with good alternatives to things I am thinking about purchasing.

Kind of like thread count on bed sheets, huh? I'm sure that makes a huge difference to YOU people when comparing 300 vs 1000 thread count.

Gots to be comphy whilst making a statement.

[ThreeFingerPete]

I just bought my xd subcompant for 399 from The Ridgeline the are a small place that does allot of gun shows

Yup. Quite common.

USP compact.

Umm. Not a sub compact.

It's a better gun . That being said if you want that 13 rd capacity he could get a p30 in .40 caliber.

Umm. Not a sub compact, and the absolute worst trigger on a >$500 gun I've ever seen. No. Fucking. Thanks.

+1 for the p30.

See above. I'm waiting for the day that I see someone shoot a p30 well. If you have small hands, the S/A might not be too bad.

[Moose242]

Yup. Quite common.

Umm. Not a sub compact.

Umm. Not a sub compact, and the absolute worst trigger on a >$500 gun I've ever seen. No. Fucking. Thanks.

See above. I'm waiting for the day that I see someone shoot a p30 well. If you have small hands, the S/A might not be too bad.

The OP specified a glock 23, which is a compact (not a sub compact).

[ThreeFingerPete]

The OP specified a glock 23, which is a compact (not a sub compact).

Yes, and a few posts down, we clarified what class of gun would be comparable to a sub compact XD.